Connect with us

World

Geopolitical winds raise Israel’s threat perception of Iran but major strike unlikely


Ahead of a military drill simulating war with Iran, Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said: “I have a sharp, clear message for Iran and the international community: Israel will do what it must to prevent Iran from getting a nuclear bomb.”

Much of the recent Israeli rhetoric on Iran has been a series of expressions of heightened concern over the developments of Iran’s nuclear program and threats of taking unilateral action should its principal ally, the US, disprove of conducting a military strike against Tehran.

Israel’s unease is intensified by Tehran’s latest flurry of diplomatic activity, especially in light of the China-brokered normalization agreement with Saudi Arabia and the military alliance with Russia.

Additionally, since the beginning of this year, Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi made state visits to and signed various multilateral cooperation agreements with China, Syria, Indonesia, and three US-sanctioned countries in South America: Cuba, Nicaragua and Venezuela.

Raisi’s Foreign Minister Hossein Amir-Abdollahian hosted his Saudi counterpart Prince Faisal bin Farhan in a landmark visit to Tehran, and made a three-leg tour of the Gulf, where he met with his counterparts in Qatar, Kuwait and Oman – a mediator of indirect talks between Iran and the US.

Furthermore, the US and Iran reportedly restarted talks to place limitations on Tehran’s nuclear program, releasing detained US citizens and unfreezing some Iranian assets.

Netanyahu has repeatedly warned Washington that Israel would not be bound by any deal it strikes with Tehran. He recently stressed: “Our position is clear: Israel will not be bound by any deal with Iran and will continue to defend itself.”

Level of Iranian threat to Israel

Currently, the political landscapes have started shifting slightly, as Iran seems to be emerging out of isolation and appears to be employing a selective strategy of openness through finding potential partnerships with countries of similar “anti-West” mindsets. It’s also hoping to utilize the détente with Saudi Arabia to herald more normalization deals with other regional players such as Egypt and the UAE.

Those developments, in addition to the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) reporting earlier this year finding uranium enriched to 84 percent in Iran – very close to the required 90 percent weapons grade, make Israel feel evermore threatened by Iran.

Netanyahu said earlier this month: “The reality in our region is changing rapidly. We are not stagnating. We are adjusting our war doctrine and our options of action in accordance with these changes, in accordance with our goals which do not change.”

Senior fellow for Israel Affairs at the Middle East Institute, Nimrod Goren, told Al Arabiya English: “Israel treats the Iranian threat very seriously, and sees it as possibly existential. It is the major regional threat Israel is currently facing… There is a political consensus and determination in Israel about the need to dismantle this threat, even though different political leaders may have differing ideas on which course of action should be taken.”

Adjunct senior fellow for Middle East studies at the Council of Foreign Relations, Henri Barkey, concurred: “One should not underestimate Israel’s deep psychological fear of an Iranian bomb; it is existential, no question. This is one issue on which all sides in Israel agree and the Iranian behavior over time has deepened these perceptions.”

Israel’s threat level perception of Iran seems to be at an all time high given the current geopolitical winds, and what may seem to be public posturing – to a degree, analysts argue could potentially materialize as action.

“Israel will do everything in its power to disrupt Iran’s activities in all areas, from economy to politics to infrastructure,” Barkey said.

Likelihood of unilateral military strike

The Israeli government, both current and former, has threatened to act alone against Iran if push came to shove. Netanyahu recently said: “We are sure and confident that we can deal with any threat on our own.”

However, analysts argued that a unilateral military strike was unlikely.

“Israel emphasizes its capacity to act alone vis-a-vis Iran, but over the years clearly preferred to be coordinated with the US and other allies on security issues, including the Iran file,” Goren said.

He posited: “Israel’s main goal is to prevent Iran from becoming a nuclear state, and from having the capacity to quickly become one once it decides to do so. Israel is likely to continue to take actions of different sorts to promote its interests, and to project serious intentions, although a military strike doesn’t seem to be Israel’s desired course of action.”

Barkey agreed: “It is very hard to see Israel acting alone in a major strike. It would need at the very least US logistical and intelligence support. [Also] support would also be needed in the event something goes wrong.”

“I would also say that an [Israeli] major strike [against Iran] is likely to create a tsunami of aftereffects worldwide, oil prices, international economy, something that no one wants to see.”

US involvement in a potential Israeli strike against Iran

As for the likelihood of the US taking part in an Israeli military strike against Iran’s nuclear program, that depends on several key factors, explained senior director of the Rafik Hariri Center and Middle East Programs at the Atlantic Council, William Wechsler.

Wechsler said that if Israeli leadership determined that a military strike is the only option to prevent or delay Iran’s acquisition of nuclear weapons and believed they had the necessary capabilities to do so unilaterally, without a direct provocation from Iran, and against the objections of the US, then the involvement of the US becomes unlikely.

However, if any of these circumstances do not apply, such as if there was a direct Iranian action prompting Israeli response or if there was alignment with US desires, then the probability of US involvement increases.

Saudi-Iran normalization vs Saudi-Israel normalization?

Israel, since the signing of the US-sponsored Abraham Accords normalizing ties with UAE, Bahrain, Sudan and Morocco, has continued to seek expanding the initiative to other regional countries. Israeli politicians have repeatedly stressed that establishing ties with Saudi Arabia would be the ultimate achievement and would be pivotal to establishing peace in the region.

In April, Netanyahu said that normalization of ties with Saudi Arabia would serve as a “giant leap” towards ending the Arab-Israeli conflict.

Meanwhile, Saudi Arabia has repeatedly stated that any kind of peace accord or deal to normalize ties with Israel would be preconditioned on the establishment of an independent Palestinian state.

Israeli officials have touted Iran and its threat to the region – including its nuclear program, ballistic missiles arsenal, and its interference through arming and financing militias in countries such as Yemen, Lebanon, Iraq and Syria – as a shared enemy with Arab countries.

Israel saw the China-brokered deal normalizing ties between Saudi Arabia and Iran as a setback to its goals of establishing ties with the Kingdom.

However, analysts argue that normalization with Iran would not have a negative impact on the potential of normalizing ties with Israel.

Wechsler argued that the normalization of relations with Iran was part of a wider strategy of de-escalation of tensions seen recently from Riyadh. “We’ve seen it with Turkey, Qatar and most recently Syria.”

“This larger strategy doesn’t make it less likely that Saudi Arabia will normalize relations with Israel. I actually think the contrary is true, that [the strategy] makes it more likely that there will be normalization with Israel as the predicate is set,” Wechsler said.

Goren also said: “The [Saudi-Iran] rapprochement didn’t impact for the negative the Israeli interest in normalization with the Saudis, nor is it reflected in the reported Saudi demands from the US for normalization to happen.”

Read more:

Israel: ‘All possible means on the table’ to prevent Iran getting nuclear weapons

Israel accuses UN nuclear watchdog of ‘capitulating’ to Iran

Israel’s window to strike Iran narrows as Putin enters equation

Iran: Saudi Arabia detente to positively affect our ties with Egypt, Jordan, Bahrain

Saudi FM: Agreement with Iran doesn’t translate to resolving all differences

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

World

Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi meets with CEOs of leading Norwegian companies

H.H. Sheikh Khaled bin Mohamed bin Zayed Al Nahyan, Crown Prince of Abu Dhabi, has met with a group of CEOs from leading Norwegian companies, as part of their participation in the UAE-Norway Investment Forum, held alongside his official visit to the Kingdom of Norway.

During the meeting, H.H. Sheikh Khaled bin Mohamed bin Zayed underscored the UAE leadership’s commitment to strengthening economic cooperation with its international partners.

He highlighted that investment in innovation and knowledge is a cornerstone for achieving sustainable development, noting that enhancing collaboration with Norwegian companies across key sectors will open new avenues for mutual economic growth between the two countries.

The UAE-Norway Investment Forum, taking place in Oslo, aimed to highlight available investment opportunities and strengthen trade relations between the UAE and Norway, fostering shared interests and supporting innovation and knowledge-based economic visions.

-wam

Continue Reading

World

At the Indonesia International Book Fair 2024, TRENDS inaugurates 10th global office, releases four books

As part of its Asian research tour, partnership with Aletihad News Center, and
primary sponsorship of the Indonesia International Book Fair 2024, TRENDS
Research & Advisory inaugurated its office in Jakarta, marking its 10th location
worldwide. It also released four books in Indonesian.
The inauguration event was attended by ambassadors of the UAE, Bahrain, and
Jordan to Indonesia, chairpersons of the UAE and Indonesian Publishers’
Associations, the Director of TRENDS’ Jakarta office, and a group of researchers
and academics.
Speaking at the event, Dr. Mohammed Abdullah Al-Ali, CEO of TRENDS
Research & Advisory, stated that TRENDS’ international offices—set to reach 15
by the end of 2024—aim to enhance the Center’s research efforts and deepen its
role in disseminating knowledge, thus serving as a global knowledge bridge.
He emphasized, “At TRENDS, we believe in the importance of cooperation
between think tanks and prioritize this endeavor. We believe the TRENDS office in
Jakarta will enhance the exchange of knowledge and ideas between think tanks in
Asia and the Middle East, opening new horizons for collaboration in various
fields.”

Four books in Indonesian
As part of the Jakarta office’s inaugural activities, four books were released in
Indonesian, including the 11th and 12th books of the Muslim Brotherhood
Encyclopedia and Global Trends in AI and Automation and the Future of
Competition between Man and Machine: An Analytical Forward-looking Vision.

Hostility to Arab states
The 11th book of the Muslim Brotherhood Encyclopedia, The Concept of the State
According to the Muslim Brotherhood, highlights its hostile stance toward Arab
states since its inception. The group views them as an obstacle to its ascent to
power. It opposed the modern principles upon which these states were built,
considering them incompatible with the group’s unique interpretation of Islam,
which it claimed to embody exclusively.

Exclusion of nonconformists
The 12th book, The Muslim Brotherhood: Rejection of Tolerance and Exclusion of
Nonconformists, examines the Muslim Brotherhood’s stance towards
nonconformists, individuals, and entities. The book reveals the group’s binary view
of the world, categorizing others as allies or adversaries. It ties these relationships
to the Brotherhood’s internal power struggles and self-serving interests.

Global Trends in AI
The third book, Global Trends in AI, explores significant developments in AI and
its impact on various aspects of life, including the economy, society, and
governance. It also offers a comprehensive analysis of technological advancements
in AI, its applications across sectors, the ethical and social challenges it presents,
and its future trajectory.

Automation

The fourth book, Automation and the Future of Competition between Man and
Machine: An Analytical Forward-looking Vision, addresses the growing challenges
faced by the human workforce in the face of widespread automation and AI
applications. The book concludes that while automation presents a significant
challenge to the labor market, it simultaneously creates new opportunities. It
emphasizes the importance of preparing for this shift through skills development,
continuous education, and adopting economic and social policies that support the
workforce.

Prominent pavilion and active presence
The TRENDS’ pavilion at the Indonesia International Book Fair has attracted
numerous visitors, including academic researchers and officials, such as the
ambassadors of the UAE, Bahrain, Qatar, Jordan, and Turkey. Additionally,
chairpersons of Arab and Indonesian publishers’ associations, authors, publishers,
and students visited the pavilion. All were impressed with and praised TRENDS’ diverse, valuable publications. They also commended TRENDS’ active
international presence and ability to address global developments with rigorous
analytical research.
Dr. Mohammed Abdullah Al-Ali honored the esteemed guests, including
ambassadors of the UAE and Bahrain to Indonesia, Wedha Startesti Yudha,
Chairperson of the Indonesia International Book Fair Committee, Arys Hilman
Nugraha, Chairman of the Indonesian Publishers Association, and others,
presenting them with TRENDS’ publications and commemorative shields.
Additionally, he awarded TRENDS’ Research Medal to Ni Made Ayu Martini
Indonesian Deputy Minister of Marketing, Tourism and Creative Economy
It is worth noting that during its current Asian research tour, TRENDS announced
the launch of the TRENDS Research Medal, awarded to individuals who make
significant contributions to the development of scientific research and promote collaboration with TRENDS in strengthening a culture of research across various fields.

Continue Reading

World

US determined to prevent full-scale war in Middle East, Joe Biden tells UNGA79

US President Joe Biden highlighted the US Administration’s determination to prevent a wider war that engulfs the entire Middle East region, noting that a diplomatic solution “remains the only path to lasting security to allow the residents from both countries to return to their homes on the border safely”.

In remarks he made today before the 79th Session of the United Nations General Assembly (UNGA79), the US President said, “Full-scale war is not in anyone’s interest,” adding that a diplomatic solution is still possible.

He also touched on “the rise of violence against innocent Palestinians on the West Bank”, and the need to “set the conditions for a better future”, which he said featured “a two-state solution, where the world — where Israel enjoys security and peace and full recognition and normalised relations with all its neighbours, where Palestinians live in security, dignity, and self-determination in a state of their own”.

President Biden underscored the ceasefire and hostage deal put forth by Qatar and Egypt, which the UN Security Council endorsed. He said, “Now is the time for the parties to finalise its terms, bring the hostages home,” adding that this would help ease the suffering in Gaza, and end the war.

-WAM

Continue Reading

Trending